Part 5
Nora brought the pencil toward the page. Its sharp point hovered below the first note of the measure, just beyond the stretch of music her mother had marked.
The clock above the door clicked through the remaining minutes. Nora shifted the pencil, trying to find a place for the number that didn’t seem too close to Mara’s last words.
Judith waited until the lesson was over before taking it back.
“We can leave the page today.” She closed the book and put the invention on top. “These four measures for Tuesday. Slowly enough to keep both hands even.”
For three weeks, Nora worked at things the paper keyboard had never asked of her. She learned to let her forearm loosen while a finger held a note, to lift without jerking, and to stop before tired hands began to stiffen.
On one Saturday, the nocturne’s opening went better than it ever had at home with Mara. The following Tuesday, Nora lost the same entrance four times and couldn’t clear the pedal quickly enough to keep the harmonies distinct.
Judith moved her pencil toward the unmarked section.
“You won’t find your mother here.”
Nora closed the score. The cover caught Judith’s finger, but Nora was already off the bench.
She sat on the former library’s stone steps with her bag against her knees. Judith didn’t come after her. When Ben arrived, Nora stood before he could ask why she was outside.
At the next lesson, Judith was waiting near the practice-room door.
“I spoke badly last week,” she said. “I meant that your mother can’t tell me what she intended for that passage. I said something else.”
Nora kept hold of her backpack strap.
Judith adjusted the edge of her thumb brace. “You may come in and work on the left hand. Or we can try again next week.”
Nora went past her and put the invention on the piano.
Getting there took more arranging than Nora had understood. Ben slept a few hours after a night shift, traded evenings with Curtis, and once reached the center with his work shirt buttoned crookedly under his jacket. Their car overheated if traffic held it still too long. Saturday practice meant two buses and a walk through streets where winter grit still lay thick beside the curbs.
One Monday, she found Ben asleep at the kitchen table. The lesson calendar lay under his elbow, beside an electric bill. His work phone vibrated against a spoon without waking him.
Nora stood there until it stopped.
The next morning, she asked to use the school office phone. She called the music center and said they had to give up her place.
The receptionist asked for Ben’s confirmation.
“He’s working,” Nora said.
“We’ll need to speak with him before we—”
Nora thanked her and hung up. That afternoon, she stayed in aftercare instead of meeting Ben for the trip to her lesson.
At breakfast on Wednesday, he laid an attendance notice beside her bowl.
“The center called. I want to hear what happened from you.”
“You need more sleep.”
He pulled out the chair opposite her. “Nora.”
“I told them we couldn’t come anymore.”
“When were you going to tell me?”
She pushed a piece of cereal beneath the milk.
“You didn’t tell me about Mom’s music.”
“No. I made that decision for both of us, and I shouldn’t have.”
He turned the notice over. On the back, he had written out the shifts Curtis could still cover and the weekend shift Ben would take in exchange after that. There was a bus departure time beneath the lesson hour.
“The electric bill’s paid,” he said. “That was the copy I needed to file.”
Nora studied the schedule. He had squeezed one line into the margin and drawn an arrow back to Tuesday.
“I can’t make this look easy,” he said. “But you can’t cancel my plans because you find me asleep.”
“What if they’ve given it to somebody else?”
“Call them.”
She did, with Ben sitting beside her. The place was still hers, but the receptionist explained that another absence without a properly approved cancellation would end the trial.
Nora apologized. Then she asked to speak to Judith and apologized again.
Judith waited through the pause afterward.
“I can make up the lesson Saturday,” she said. “Ten o’clock.”
That morning, Nora returned to the measure she had been unable to mark. She tried the change three times, chose the fingering that let her wrist stay easy, and wrote a small 2 beneath the note.
The graphite looked much darker than Mara’s. Nora turned the pencil toward the eraser, held it there, then put it on the rack without rubbing anything out.
By late April, the school and the center were preparing a joint arts night. Money from tickets and small donations helped support access placements like hers.
An outreach coordinator brought a proposed program to Dr. Whitcomb’s office. Nora sat beside Ben while the woman explained that she hoped to use Nora’s experience to show what the fund made possible.
The paragraph included the classroom performance, Mara’s death, the sale of the upright, and the paper keyboard. The coordinator also asked whether the keys could be photographed for a lobby display.
“You can refuse all of this,” she said. “It has no bearing on your place at the center.”
Nora read the paragraph again. It took less than a minute. Her mother’s illness, the movers, and all the evenings at the kitchen table fit inside a block of type no longer than a homework question.
Ben ran his thumb along the bottom of the sheet.
“People might see it and help pay for someone else’s lessons,” he said.
Nora looked at him. “They need Mom for that?”
“Nora, I’m talking about helping—”
“First her piano goes. Then her music disappears into a box. Now you want everybody looking at her in the lobby.”
Ben’s thumb stopped moving.
“That piano paid hospital bills,” he said. “And it kept the roof over us for four more months.”
She knew. She looked down at her score, but his hand remained in the edge of her sight.
The coordinator closed her folder halfway.
“We can put this aside and talk another day.”
“No,” Nora said. “I want to play. I don’t want this printed, and nobody gets the keyboard.”
The woman drew a line through the paragraph.
“Then tell me what you’d like us to announce.”
Nora rested her hands on the score’s cover.
“Just who I am. What I’m playing…”
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇