Part 6
Colin arrived at Judith’s office on the first Monday of November with rain darkening his jacket shoulders. A paper envelope had softened where his fingers gripped it.
Daniel and Rafael were already seated. Colin stopped when he saw them.
“I wasn’t sure you’d want to talk to me.”
Daniel stood and moved a chair away from the table.
“Sit down.”
Judith closed the door. Natalie put her laptop beside her, but the lawyer asked her to leave it shut for the moment.
“We’ll establish what Mr. Marsh is here to provide first.”
She explained that nobody wanted him to obtain material he had no right to take or make allegations beyond his knowledge. He could provide information he was entitled to share and identify records investigators should request.
Colin nodded. His fingers remained on the envelope.
For years, he said, his job had been ordinary coordination: transport arrangements, intake forms, holding records, helping owners find the right office. He had believed the work mattered.
“Then the measures changed. Intake targets. Processing speed. More categories for extra services.”
“Contract requirements?” Natalie asked.
“Some connected to the contract. Some internal.”
Judith asked whether anyone had expressly ordered false entries.
“Not using those words.”
“Then use only the words and actions you remember.”
Reports began coming back for correction after fieldwork was complete. A location would change. An animal claimed by an owner might remain in an unidentified-stray category. Holding dates didn’t always match the original communications.
“At first, I thought we were fixing mistakes.” Colin rubbed one palm against his trousers. “After a while, they were always the same mistakes.”
Rafael leaned forward.
“Juniper?”
Colin looked at him directly.
“I remember an adult shepherd and several pups. The preliminary description mentioned fenced property, near a farm entrance. The final summary put them on a road.”
He had asked Wade about it. Wade said the location had been verified and told him to finish processing.
“When did you know she was ours?” Rafael asked.
“Not at the beginning. Later. When your inquiries came in, I knew something wasn’t right.”
“Why didn’t you tell us?”
Colin’s eyes dropped.
“I wanted to keep my job.”
Rain ticked against the window. Rafael sat back, hands clasped tightly, and said nothing.
Judith asked to see what Colin had brought.
The envelope contained ordinary employment correspondence he had retained, including a dated message about revised reporting expectations. He also identified what authorities should obtain: original field reports, modification histories, billing summaries, and authorizations.
Natalie opened her laptop after Judith nodded.
“A changed location gives us a question,” she said. “The history may tell us who changed it and when. Then we need the reason.”
“And payment records,” Colin added. “To see what was billed.”
He repeatedly distinguished what he remembered from what he didn’t know. He could not explain every file or establish a complete scheme.
Near the end, he spoke about a man who had called three times over an extra fee.
“I kept sending him to billing. I knew he wasn’t getting an answer.”
“What name?” Daniel asked.
“Walter Pike.”
Daniel thought of the old man turning his cap between his hands.
Colin stared at the table.
“I keep hearing him ask.”
Daniel let the quiet remain for a moment.
“You can’t undo those calls,” he said. “Tell the truth about them now.”
Colin nodded and gave Judith the dates he remembered.
Over the next several days, the families authorized a formal request for independent review. Ruth contributed her call history. Walter supplied the notice. The Serranos gave Juniper’s ownership and medical records and their correspondence.
Elise prepared a comparison that identified each inconsistency without drawing conclusions outside the records. Deputy Greer reviewed the concerns about animal collection and forwarded them to the appropriate investigative office.
Daniel spent one afternoon making copies, stopping to call a family whenever Judith needed clarification. The original documents stayed in their owners’ hands or went through the proper process. By evening, the request was ready to submit.
Martin Ellery’s response came through company representatives. Velcora maintained that it had fulfilled the contract and that the discrepancies were administrative. Colin, the response suggested, had left because he was dissatisfied and could not be relied upon.
Daniel read that section twice.
“Still doesn’t explain the changes.”
“No,” Natalie said. “But we’re not answering a personal attack with another one.”
“When did you become so measured?”
“When the vacancy opened in this family.”
He looked over his glasses. She smiled, and he laughed.
Outside, the basin’s higher slopes had gathered snow. Daniel took the sticking coop door down one morning rather than plan another temporary adjustment.
Natalie brought a toolbox.
“Do you know what any of those are?” he asked.
“The heavy one’s for correcting your attitude.”
“Good. Hold this.”
They straightened the frame and replaced a worn hinge. Benedict stayed on a short leash secured within Daniel’s reach, watching until a leaf demanded investigation.
“Sit,” Daniel told him.
The puppy sat.
“Wait.”
For several seconds, he did. Then Beatrice clucked from the other side, and his entire attention swung toward her.
Daniel redirected him.
“You’re assigned to me.”
“He’s bilingual,” Natalie said. “You and chicken.”
“Chicken appears to be his first language.”
Beatrice stood by the doorway, inspecting the hinge. Her comb leaned at its familiar angle.
“Mom would have given her a desk,” Natalie said.
“And billed me for the lumber.”
The door swung cleanly when they rehung it. Daniel tested the latch twice.
“Your mother told me to fix that properly.”
“She was right.”
“As a rule.”
He reached for the toolbox, still smiling.
Pauline arrived while they were washing their hands. She took in both of them, the repaired door, and Benedict tangled thoughtfully around a chair leg.
“No resignations?” she asked.
“Not before lunch,” Daniel said.
She carried apples into the kitchen. The table had been cleared for meals; the files now lived in labeled boxes in the adjoining room. Caroline’s tins were still close at hand, but Natalie could put down a cutting board without asking permission.
Pauline turned an apple in her hand.
“These will bake well.”
Daniel looked at it.
“No deadline,” she added.
“Maybe soon.”
At supper, he chopped carrots while Natalie cut bread. They ate soup at the same end of the table, with no records between them.
She reminded him of the oatmeal cookies Caroline had once salted by mistake.
“She said the labels were confusing,” Daniel said.
“She changed the containers herself.”
“She maintained her position.”
“She told me not to tell you.”
“Your loyalty’s lasted admirably.”
Natalie laughed. Benedict lifted his head at the sound of a spoon, received nothing, and went back to his toy.
Two days later, Judith called. The administrative body responsible for the contract had scheduled a public hearing for later in November. It would examine performance, documented discrepancies, and residents’ concerns. It would not decide every legal issue, and the outcome remained open.
She wanted Daniel to prepare a short statement about his own experience.
“Finding the puppy. Wade’s visit. The veterinarian. Your efforts to identify the family. Stay with what you witnessed.”
“I can do a report.”
“Then do that. You needn’t conduct the investigation from a microphone.”
The blank sheet on the table proved harder than he expected. Daniel wrote a formal opening, crossed it out, and tried again.
Natalie sat beside him.
“What do you want them to hear?”
He thought about Ruth’s leash and Walter’s cap. Rafael crouched by the barrier. Colin unable to look up.
“That there are people attached to these files.”
She pushed the paper back toward him.
“Write that without trying to sound official.”
The night before the hearing, he read aloud in the kitchen. His glasses lay beside the page; he had decided he could see it well enough without them.
He began with the farm, then started again with the puppy in the nesting box. Benedict lifted his head at his name.
“Yes. Your unusual entrance.”
Daniel read the facts, stopping whenever a phrase sounded larger than what he knew. Near the end, his voice failed.
He lowered the paper and looked at Caroline’s apron.
Benedict got up and pressed against his leg.
“I’ve been less nervous doing worse things,” Daniel told him.
The puppy leaned harder.
Daniel put a hand on his back, took a breath, and lifted the page again…
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇