Part 2
I drove home with the radio off. In the parking lot, I checked the email confirming that the small apartment I’d found would be ready for me. Then I went upstairs.
Derek was stretched out on the couch. He lowered the television volume when I stood in front of him instead of sitting down.
“I heard you at Brent’s,” I said.
His expression barely changed at first.
“What are you talking about?”
“The kitchen window was open. I heard what you said about me. And Paige.”
He sat upright.
For a few seconds he watched me as though I might supply a different explanation. Then he began talking so quickly that one excuse ran into another. They’d been joking. People said stupid things around their friends. He’d had a few drinks. I knew he loved me.
I waited until he stopped.
“Then ask me to marry you.”
He stared at me.
“No ring. No audience. Ask.”
“You can’t spring something like that on me.”
“You’ve had five years.”
He rubbed his forehead. “I’m not ready.”
I went to the bedroom and took the suitcase down from the closet shelf.
He followed me, arguing now, saying I was turning one dumb conversation into something huge. I put folded clothes into the case while he spoke. When he tried to take my hand, I stepped around him to get my shoes.
Nolan helped carry my boxes into the new apartment. He didn’t try to make the day romantic. He hauled things up the stairs, asked where I wanted the dresser, and left when I said I needed to sleep.
The next morning, Derek discovered that readiness could apparently be found overnight. He called, then texted, then called again. We could fix this. He would change. If a proposal was what I needed, he would do it.
I set the phone facedown on the floor and unpacked a lamp.
For a month, Nolan and I kept a careful distance from anything we couldn’t name honestly. We still talked. He checked whether I’d eaten on nights I worked late. I bought curtains, learned the sounds of the building, and got used to opening a refrigerator that contained only things I liked.
Then Nolan asked me out.
“An actual date,” he said. “No pretending we’re just discussing the coffee.”
“Yes,” I told him.
We knew his family would have questions. Neither of us expected Derek to answer them by knocking over a water glass.
It happened at the next family dinner. Nolan and I arrived together and sat beside each other. We hadn’t made an announcement. His aunt was asking about somebody’s new roof when Derek’s chair dragged backward with a screech.
The glass went over as he stood. Water spread toward a basket of rolls.
“You’ve got to be kidding me.”
Conversation stopped. Beneath the table, Nolan took my hand.
Derek pointed at us. His face had gone blotchy, and his fingers were shaking.
“My own cousin. That’s who you leave me for?”
His mother looked from him to me, then down at where our hands met near the edge of the table.
“Sit down,” his father said. “You can talk without shouting.”
Derek acted as though he hadn’t heard.
He told the room that Nolan had taken his girlfriend, that we’d gone behind his back, that his cousin had torn the family apart. An aunt pressed her napkin to her mouth. Someone at the far end said, “Oh, no.”
I opened my mouth, but Nolan had already let go of my hand and risen.
“She ended the relationship and moved out a month before our first date,” he said. “You know that.”
Derek called him a liar.
“No,” Nolan said. “You’re angry. That doesn’t let you change what happened.”
He stood with his arms at his sides. I could see a muscle moving in his jaw, though his voice stayed even.
“You don’t have to like this. You do have to stop yelling at her.”
Valerie pushed her chair back.
I braced myself. For years she’d commented on the price of my clothes, questioned whether my job was really as demanding as I said, and greeted me with the kind of smile that made me check whether I’d brought the wrong dish.
“Oh, sit down, Derek,” she said. “You’re making a fool of yourself.”
He turned on her. “Stay out of it.”
“No. I watched you let her do everything for you. She was decent to every difficult person at this table, including me, and you barely noticed.”
Valerie looked at me then.
“I’m glad somebody did. I hope you two are happy.”
For a moment, I could only stare at her.
Derek accused his sister of turning against him, too. His mother stood so abruptly that her napkin fell to the floor.
“Enough. Both of you.”
She came around the table and touched my elbow.
“Come help me in the kitchen.”
I followed her through the door. A pan of chicken sat on the stove, and the dishwasher hummed beneath the counter. She turned toward me before we reached the sink.
“Tell me what happened,” she said. “Please. I’m not asking for his version.”
I told her about the cookout. She listened without interrupting while I described standing inside Brent’s house, hearing her son explain that I was useful company until the woman he really wanted came back.
When I said Paige’s name, her lips parted.
“I thought we were building a life,” I said. “He knew I thought that.”
She reached for me before I finished. We stood beside the stove with her arms around my waist and my face pressed against her hair.
“I’m sorry,” she said. “I believed him, too.”
She stepped back far enough to look at me. Tears had slipped into the fine lines beside her nose.
“I used to think about what I’d wear to your wedding. Isn’t that foolish? I was picking out a dress in my head while he was wasting your time.”
I shook my head, but she held my shoulders.
“You gave him five years. You don’t owe him the rest.”
From the other room, Derek’s voice rose again.
His mother glanced toward the door, then back at me. “Nolan’s a good man. You’re allowed to be happy with him.”
I was crying by then. She pulled me close once more, and we stayed there until the front door banged shut.
A motor started outside. Tires scraped against the pavement, followed by the sharp sound of acceleration. We waited until it faded before returning to the dining room.
Grant, Nolan’s older brother, surveyed the damp tablecloth.
“Well,” he said, “Derek’s never needed much help finding an exit.”
A few people gave uncertain laughs. Nolan’s father said perhaps a drive would cool him off. Someone passed the potatoes, and dinner resumed in cautious fragments.
His aunt asked about my promotion. An uncle recommended a restaurant to Nolan and me, repeating the directions when I couldn’t quite concentrate. Their grandmother reached across the small space between our places and laid her hand over mine.
“Glad we’re not losing you,” she said.
I turned my hand beneath hers and held on.
Derek’s messages filled the following week. At breakfast he wanted another chance. At midnight he accused me of using his cousin to hurt him. Sometimes there were apologies followed minutes later by names I wouldn’t have repeated aloud.
I saved every message before I blocked him.
The silence lasted until mutual friends began sending screenshots of his social media. He had discovered a seemingly endless supply of quotations about disloyal relatives and untrustworthy people. There were articles about escaping unhealthy relationships, as though someone had held him captive in ours.
I showed Nolan one while we were waiting for takeout.
He read it, handed back my phone, and said, “He can write all night. Our food’s getting cold.”
That Saturday, Simone arrived with coffee and the determination to finish unpacking my apartment. I’d lived there six weeks, but there were still dishes wrapped in paper and pictures propped against the bedroom wall.
She watched me open a carton, then asked whether I was certain I wanted another relationship so soon.
“I’m not judging,” she said. “I just don’t want you rushing because being alone hurts.”
“I was alone before I left,” I told her.
I explained the two months after the cookout, when I’d still slept beside Derek but had already stopped believing anything he said about us. By the time I moved out, I’d spent weeks grieving a relationship he hadn’t noticed was gone. It had been nearly four months since that afternoon at Brent’s.
Simone took a mug from its wrapping and placed it in the cupboard.
“Okay,” she said slowly. “That’s different.”
She kept her back to me as she reached for another.
“There’s something I should’ve said to you years ago…”
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇
