The Table by the Window

Part 5

Caleb was at the kitchen table when I ended the call. I sat across from him, turning my phone over in my hands.

“We could say we have plans,” I said.

“We could.” He waited. “But I don’t want him deciding which family dinners we get to attend.”

Neither did I. We agreed to go, with one condition: if Brandon started anything, we would leave. Caleb said Jonah would help keep things from getting out of hand.

I wrote Thanksgiving on the calendar beside the refrigerator.

On the morning itself, I changed my mind about clothes three times before Caleb brought coffee into the bedroom. He sat on the edge of the mattress while I held two sweaters against myself.

“We can leave before dinner,” he said. “We can leave before we take our coats off. You know that, right?”

I put one sweater back in the drawer.

Jonah called around ten to say he would be there early. He could occupy Brandon if necessary. The practical kindness of that made me laugh for the first time all morning.

We brought a pie from a bakery because I’d been too nervous to make one. Caleb carried it while we walked up the driveway, past Brandon’s truck near the garage.

His mother opened the door before we knocked and hugged us both. Behind her, I could smell turkey, butter, and onions cooking in something I’d want seconds of later.

Brandon sat with his father in front of the football game. He looked up, saw us, and returned his attention to the television.

Jonah appeared at Caleb’s shoulder, asking about drinks. We followed him into the kitchen, where Vanessa was mashing potatoes with more force than the task required.

“Glad you came,” she said, handing me a spoon to taste them.

The afternoon moved slowly. People talked about work, weather, a repair someone needed on a roof. Brandon remained quiet through dinner, passing dishes when asked and keeping his attention near his own plate.

Afterward, his mother found me in the hallway.

“He’s been in therapy for about a month,” she said. “He’s trying to work through this instead of taking it out on everybody.”

“I’m glad.”

“So am I.” She hugged me. “I’d like us all to be able to breathe at these things again.”

Later, when most guests had gone, I was fitting lids onto leftover containers in the kitchen. Brandon stopped in the doorway.

“Could I talk to you for a minute?”

My fingers tightened around a lid.

“Just talk,” he added. “Out back, if that’s okay.”

I nodded.

The porch was cold enough that I folded my arms across my chest. Brandon kept both hands in his pockets and studied a worn place in the boards.

“I treated you badly,” he said. “When we were together. Afterward, too.”

I let him continue.

“I took it for granted that you’d be there. Then you weren’t, and I acted like that was something you’d done to me.”

He looked toward the yard.

“My therapist keeps bringing me back to how much of my life I spent staring backward. I had somebody there, and I was busy thinking about something that ended in college.”

His voice caught when he mentioned Caleb.

“It hurts seeing you with him. But I understand why you left.” He finally looked at me. “I know we’re not going to be friends. I hope you can forgive me someday.”

“I accept your apology,” I said. “But I need the boundaries to stay where I put them. No showing up. No messages trying to start it all again. And no more making family gatherings something I have to prepare myself for.”

He nodded.

“I’m trying to move on.”

“I hope you do.”

We stood for a moment listening to dishes being stacked inside. Then I went in first.

Caleb was waiting in the living room. He searched my face when I sat beside him, and I rested my hand on his knee. I told him the whole conversation in the car on the way home.

He let out a breath and kept his eyes on the road.

“Good,” he said. “I hope he keeps doing the work.”

Christmas was easier. New Year’s was easier still. Brandon stayed courteous and kept his distance. At a dinner his mother hosted, he made a joke that included Caleb and me, then laughed without looking to see whether anyone was uncomfortable.

I stopped tracking where he stood whenever Caleb touched my back or made me laugh. After the holidays, I took his number off the blocked list, though there was no reason for either of us to use it.

One night, Caleb told me he admired how I’d handled the family.

“I wasn’t graceful in my head,” I said.

He smiled. “I’m dating you, not your private commentary.”

By January, work had resumed its ordinary demands. We cooked together, took turns choosing something to watch, and argued mildly about whether a half-empty container deserved refrigerator space.

Then Caleb began closing his laptop when I entered the room.

At first, I barely noticed. After the second private phone call in the bedroom, I noticed everything. A browser window disappearing. His phone turned over quickly. A conversation finished before I could hear who was on the other end.

My body remembered things my mind wanted to dismiss. Brandon had been careful with screens, too, especially when Natalie’s name might be on one.

I didn’t look through Caleb’s phone. I didn’t ask a question designed to catch him. Sometimes I had to remind myself of that decision while standing outside the bedroom door, but I made it again.

Two weeks into January, he told me he was taking me to dinner.

“Dress up a little,” he said, then immediately looked as though he regretted how mysterious that sounded.

He changed shirts twice. On the drive, his phone lit up in the cup holder, and he checked it at a red light.

We arrived at the restaurant with the handmade pasta, the place he’d remembered when I hardly remembered telling him. At our table, he held my hand, but his palm was warm and slightly damp.

“You all right?” I asked.

“Yeah. Absolutely.”

He glanced at his phone again.

I tried to follow the conversation. He asked about work, listened, answered, then seemed to lose his place. When our main courses were cleared, he excused himself and was gone long enough for me to finish my water and begin worrying in earnest.

Almost ten minutes later, he returned. A waiter followed with two desserts we hadn’t ordered.

Caleb sat down and looked at me instead of the cake in front of him.

“Are you going to eat that?” I asked.

“Probably not.”

“Caleb.”

He gave a small, unsteady laugh. “I had a much smoother version of this planned.”

He pushed his chair back.

For a second, I thought he was leaving the table again. Then he lowered himself to one knee beside my chair, and my fork struck the plate.

He took a little box from his jacket.

“We’ve had six months together,” he said. “I don’t need more time to decide whether I want a life with you. I want the whole thing.”

The ring rested against pale fabric, a round stone on a simple band.

He looked up at me.

“Will you marry me?”
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇