The server had just cleared the spare place setting when Brooke pulled out the empty chair.
“There you are,” she said to Caleb, as if he’d been the one keeping her waiting.

I looked from her to the jacket I’d left on the chair. Caleb moved it onto the back of mine before I could reach for it.
“I thought this was dinner for two,” I said.
Brooke gave me a patient little smile. “He messaged me. Sometimes a person needs an evening that doesn’t feel so much like a relationship meeting.”
Caleb frowned at his phone. He’d answered something she’d sent earlier, apparently, but he didn’t contradict her. She settled in and started telling him about somebody from their gaming group.
By the time our food arrived, I was sitting sideways to stay in the conversation.
That was how it usually happened. There was never one enormous thing I could point to without having to explain the dozen smaller things underneath it.
At a movie the following weekend, Brooke arrived while Caleb was getting popcorn. I’d put my sweater on his seat. She handed it to me, sat down, and waved him over when he came through the door.
During the previews, she rested her head against his shoulder.
“Good thing you’re not one of those girls who polices where everybody’s elbows go,” she said to me.
I could have asked her to move. Instead, I pulled my sweater across my lap and spent half the movie furious with myself for letting her make the request feel unreasonable before I’d even made it.
At a sports bar near our campus in Ketterby, Ohio, she inspected my salad before touching her own basket of wings.
“You know you’re allowed to eat in front of your boyfriend.” She lifted her beer toward Caleb. “Some of us didn’t get the memo about surviving on leaves.”
“I ordered what I wanted.”
“Sure. I just couldn’t keep up that kind of performance.”
She said it cheerfully. That was important. Everything came wrapped in a tone that suggested anybody objecting would be spoiling the fun.
A few weeks later, Caleb complimented a dress I’d worn to an afternoon cookout. Before I could thank him, Brooke pinched the hem of her shorts.
“I need clothes that let me do things.”
Then she put her drink down and turned a cartwheel across the grass.
People clapped. I stepped out of the way so her shoe wouldn’t catch my knee, and she came up laughing, brushing grass from her palms. Caleb laughed, too. I stood there in a dress I’d liked very much when I left home.
Games gave her another opening. Whenever a group gathered around a console, she called Caleb over and demanded a match. Winning meant she got to announce that no other woman in the room could give him a decent challenge. Losing meant she wanted a rematch before anybody else got a turn.
Once, when Caleb offered me the controller, she reached across him.
“Don’t overwhelm her. You’ll have to explain which end points at the screen.”
I’d played plenty of games. Just not the one she’d claimed as her territory. I let Caleb explain the controls anyway, which somehow made me angrier than arguing would have.
Eventually she began referring to things that hadn’t happened at all.
“I’m easy,” she told him one night while we were all sitting in Marcus’s living room. “You can actually joke with me. Nobody has to spend an hour apologizing afterward.”
Her eyes flicked toward me.
Later, she mentioned how exhausting it must be when a girlfriend cried over every careless comment.
I had never cried in front of Caleb. Not once. Yet somehow Brooke had given me a reputation for it, complete with the weary boyfriend who needed rescuing.
His birthday was where I finally ran out of excuses for her.
I’d saved for weeks to buy him a watch. He’d shown it to me once in a store window, then looked at the price and kept walking. I remembered the way he’d gone back for a second look.
Brooke arrived with an envelope and made sure everyone was watching when she handed it over.
Inside were two concert tickets.
“Your girlfriend would hate it,” she told Caleb before he’d finished reading them. “Too loud, too crowded. I figured you should go with somebody who’ll actually enjoy the band.”
I liked live music. She’d never asked me about that, either.
Someone asked what she’d bought him, and she held up two fingers.
“A proper night out. I couldn’t just grab a bottle of cologne and pretend I’d put thought into it.”
My gift was still in my bag. I’d told nobody what it was.
Caleb was sitting on the end of the couch when she dropped into his lap. An armchair stood empty beside him. There were two dining chairs against the wall, too.
“Nowhere left,” she announced, shifting until he moved his arm out of her way.
He laughed awkwardly. I looked straight at him. For a moment I thought he might stand up or point to a chair, but someone called his name from the kitchen, and the moment passed.
When I finally brought out the watch, Brooke reached the package first.
“Oh, let’s see.”
I still had one hand on the ribbon when she tore through the paper.
“Brooke, that’s his.”
“I’m helping.” She opened the box and held it toward the room. “It’s nice. Very sensible. Mine comes with memories, though.”
Caleb took the box from her and thanked me. He kissed my cheek, and I tried to concentrate on that instead of the torn paper under Brooke’s shoe.
She organized shots a little later. I stayed with my wine.
“Of course you did,” she said when she saw my glass. “Somebody has to keep the predictable-girlfriend tradition alive.”
I put the glass down before I answered. I knew how easily she could turn a raised voice into evidence.
“Can we talk?”
She followed me into the narrow passage by the coats, still carrying her drink. Behind us, somebody changed the music.
“You’ve spent the whole night taking little shots at me,” I said. “And you opened a present that wasn’t yours.”
Her eyebrows went up. “We’re really doing this at his birthday?”
“I tried asking you quietly. I’m asking you quietly now. Stop.”
She leaned against the wall and studied me over the rim of her cup.
“This is exactly what I mean. Everything has to become an emotional summit with you.”
“What did you mean when you said he needed somebody fun to go with?”
“That he should get to enjoy himself without managing your feelings.”
I could hear him laughing in the other room. Brooke heard it, too. She tipped her chin toward the sound.
“Caleb likes having a woman around who doesn’t attach a romantic claim to every conversation. You could try being grateful.”
“For what?”
“For giving him somewhere to breathe.”
I folded my arms because my hands had started shaking.
“You don’t get to insult me and call it helping him.”
Her expression hardened, just briefly. Then she smiled again.
“Somebody has to give him a break from you…”
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇
