Part 4
I took a screenshot of the transcript and sent it to Tessa, who was sitting less than three feet away.
This is what I mean.
She read it, passed her phone to Elise, and stopped trying to be diplomatic.
“She does something nasty, you object, and suddenly the problem is that you’re jealous.”
One by one, the others joined in. Things I’d thought nobody else had heard came back to me: a comment in a kitchen, a joke during a game, the way Brooke interrupted whenever another woman began talking.
I left Tessa’s with my blanket under my arm and my phone full of messages I didn’t answer.
Two nights later, Caleb and I went to our usual restaurant. We’d barely ordered when a message from him appeared on my screen.
Can we talk about that post?
I looked across the table. He was sitting right there, turning his phone over in his hands.
“You could just ask me,” I said.
“I know. I was trying to figure out how.”
I put my phone away.
“Then ask.”
He wanted to know what had happened with Brooke. This time, I didn’t wait for him to arrive at every conclusion himself.
“She’s been making me feel bad for months,” I said. “I wanted one evening where I wasn’t waiting for a joke about my clothes or my food or why I’m apparently terrible at being your girlfriend.”
His gaze dropped to the table.
“I’ve heard more of it lately,” he admitted. “The way she keeps comparing herself to other women. The things she says about you and expects everybody to laugh at.”
“She’s been doing that all along.”
“I know. I should’ve listened sooner.”
He reached for my hand before the server brought our food. When she arrived, he moved our joined hands out of her way instead of letting go.
Over the next few days, Owen began messaging more often. A song he thought I’d like. A joke about a class. Something ridiculous he’d found online.
I answered warmly. Sometimes I wondered whether Brooke could see he was active and knew he wasn’t answering her. The thought pleased me, and then I felt ashamed of how much it pleased me.
I invited him to lunch with Caleb, Marcus, and me that Tuesday. He agreed before I finished explaining where we’d be.
At the food court, I kissed Caleb hello and sat close enough that our knees touched. I wasn’t going to leave Owen guessing about that part of my life.
The conversation was easy. Marcus complained about an assignment, Caleb told a story about work, and Owen explained the progress he’d made on his project. When I asked a question, he answered it without checking whether somebody would interrupt to prove they knew more.
Caleb rested his hand on my knee beneath the table.
When Owen went to get napkins, Marcus leaned toward me.
“He likes you.”
I glanced at Caleb.
“As a person,” Marcus added. “He asked if it was weird for him to hang around with us more.”
“Why would it be weird?” Caleb said. “I’m glad you two get along.”
I smiled, but I had to reach for my drink to give myself something else to do.
Owen returned, and I asked about his meeting with Professor Delaney. I cared about the answer. That made the rest harder to sort out, not easier.
When he had to leave for his afternoon lab, Caleb walked with him toward the engineering building. I stayed behind to clear the table. Marcus followed me to the trash cans, then nodded toward the bicycle racks where it was quieter.
He took out his phone.
“Owen sent me this earlier.”
The message said I was easy to talk to. He wanted to be sure Caleb didn’t mind him joining us. There was also a careful reference to people who made every interaction uncomfortable.
Marcus watched me read it.
“You actually trying to make a friend?” he asked.
“Yes.”
He waited.
“And I don’t mind Brooke noticing that he likes being around somebody who treats him like a person.”
“Okay.” He slid the phone into his pocket. “Just don’t make him pay for something she did.”
“I’m not trying to.”
“I believe you. Keep checking.”
I carried that conversation around for two days, until Brooke was waiting outside my psychology building on Thursday afternoon.
She stood beside the entrance with her arms folded. When I tried to go past, she stepped into my path.
“Why are you suddenly attached to Owen?”
A student coming down the steps glanced at us. I moved aside so he could pass.
“He’s part of our group. We’ve been hanging out.”
“Don’t do that. You know I’ve liked him forever.”
“I know you like him. That doesn’t mean he can’t have friends.”
She moved closer.
“You barely spoke to him before. Now you’re everywhere he is.”
My heart was beating hard enough that I could feel it in my throat. I kept my voice low.
“Are you hearing yourself? You’ve spent months telling me that having a boyfriend doesn’t give me the right to object to anything you do.”
“This is different. You’re using him to get at me.”
I should have acknowledged the part of that she’d gotten right. Instead, I reached for the easier answer.
“You’re awfully good at spotting manipulation when somebody else might be doing it.”
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“The comments about me. The way you push into my time with Caleb. Telling everybody I’m needy so you can look easygoing.”
She stared at me, then gave a short, angry laugh.
“So you’re admitting you’re a hypocrite.”
“I’m saying Owen’s allowed to decide who he spends time with.”
“That isn’t an answer.”
Her voice had risen. People were slowing on the path behind her. I saw a phone held chest-high and wished we were anywhere else, though I still didn’t walk away.
Brooke pointed at me.
“You pretend to be sweet, but you’re jealous and fake.”
I stepped back from her hand.
“I’ve let you talk down to me for months. In front of my own boyfriend.”
“Maybe it bothers you because he has more fun with me.”
“Caleb sees what you’re doing now.”
The words came out before I could reconsider them.
Brooke stopped moving. For a moment she looked past my shoulder, toward the people gathered near the entrance, then back at me.
“What have you been telling him?”
“He was there. He heard you.”
Her eyes traveled over the students watching us. Several had their phones out now. She pulled her bag higher on her shoulder.
“You’re a liar,” she said. “You’ve planned all of this.”
Then she turned and walked quickly toward the parking lot.
I stayed beside the steps until I could trust my legs. My hands were trembling so badly that I had trouble unlocking my phone.
Two women from my psychology class approached. The taller one, who had curly hair, asked whether I was okay.
“I’ve had a friend like that,” she said. “I’m glad you didn’t let her keep going.”
The other woman said she’d seen Brooke at a party the previous semester, making jokes about women she barely knew while checking whether the men were laughing.
“I remember thinking I’d hate to be her friend,” she said. Then she looked embarrassed. “Sorry. That sounded awful.”
“No. I know what you mean.”
I thanked them and headed home. Every few steps, I checked behind me, though Brooke had gone in the opposite direction.
Paige was studying when I came in. She shut her laptop as soon as she saw me.
“What happened?”
I got through the first few sentences, then sat on my bed because I couldn’t keep standing still. She came over and hugged me. I held on longer than I meant to.
“There were people recording,” I said into her shoulder.
She sat beside me while I told her the rest.
“I’m glad you finally said it,” she said. “But are you okay with how big this is getting?”
“I don’t know. Part of me feels great. Part of me wants to wash my face and hide for a week.”
Paige went to put the kettle on.
“You can be glad you defended yourself and still hate that people were watching.”
“I didn’t hate all of it.”
She looked back at me from our little kitchen area.
“I know.”
When she brought the tea, she asked whether I thought Brooke would leave me alone now.
I held the mug in both hands.
“I honestly don’t know.”
Caleb called that evening while the tea was still on my desk. He didn’t bother with a greeting.
“Are you all right? Brooke says you came after her outside class.”
I closed my eyes.
“I didn’t.”
“I figured. Tell me what happened.”
He let me get through it without interrupting. When I finished, he said he believed me. Then he said he hated seeing me pour so much energy into something that might not deserve it.
I set my mug down too hard.
“I spent months not making a fuss. That didn’t fix anything.”
“I didn’t mean—”
“It sounds as though the solution is still for me to put up with it more quietly.”
He was silent long enough that I could hear traffic on his end of the call.
“You’re right. That came out wrong. I’m not asking you to accept it.”
“I need you to understand that saying no takes energy, too. That doesn’t make it a waste.”
“I do understand.” He exhaled. “I’ve already told her to back off. Completely.”
We were still talking when another call came through for him. Marcus.
“Can I call you right back?”
I said yes and watched the screen go dark. Paige glanced over from her desk but didn’t ask anything. I folded the corner of my blanket, unfolded it, and waited.
Caleb called twenty minutes later.
“Marcus told me something.”
I sat up.
“About Brooke?”
“About last year. His ex used to complain that Brooke made her feel like an outsider whenever they all got together. Put her down. Made these little comparisons.”
I stared at the opposite wall.
“He didn’t take it seriously then,” Caleb continued. “He thought they just didn’t like each other. He feels terrible about it now.”
“Why did he tell you tonight?”
“Because he said I’m doing what he did.”
Caleb sounded different. Not angry with me, or even surprised by my account anymore. He spoke slowly, leaving spaces between things he usually would have rushed to explain away.
“He said most people have noticed. Everybody was hoping somebody else would deal with it.”
I rubbed my thumb over the worn edge of my phone case.
“I tried to tell you.”
“I know.” His voice dropped. “I should’ve listened the first time.”
I didn’t hurry to make that easier for him.
After a while, he said, “I’m talking to her again. No jokes, no hints. She respects you and our relationship, or she doesn’t spend time with us…”
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇
