My Friend Unwrapped My Gift to My Boyfriend. I Invited Her Crush to Our Next Hangout.

Part 5

Tessa’s invitation to another movie night appeared in the group conversation a few days later. Before anybody asked about food or which movie, three people wanted to know whether Brooke was coming.

Tessa answered that it would be a small evening with a few close friends.

That was enough. The replies turned enthusiastic.

Elise messaged me privately afterward. She said she’d been uncomfortable around Brooke for months but had kept deciding she was too easily offended. Another woman sent much the same thing later that day.

I sat with both messages open, remembering all the times I’d looked around a room and assumed I was the only person hearing it.

On Saturday morning, Brooke put up a series of posts.

Brooke had built her defense in three posts: people punished outspoken women; she’d been betrayed; anyone unable to appreciate her could leave. A sad photograph of her illustrated the betrayal.

By the time I finished looking, half the group seemed to have sent me copies. Owen apologized that I had to deal with it. Tessa read the posts as an attempt to cast Brooke as the injured one, while Marcus was incredulous that she still expected everyone to believe she’d been misunderstood.

I didn’t reply to Brooke. I did read every message about her.

The following Tuesday, Owen asked if I could help him buy a birthday gift for his sister. She was turning sixteen, and he’d apparently rejected every idea he’d come up with.

We arranged to meet at the mall after his Thursday classes.

He arrived in a hoodie, holding his phone open to a list.

“I need you to tell me if any of these are terrible.”

“Are we protecting your feelings or buying your sister a present?”

“Present. Be brutal.”

His sister liked art and photography. As we walked, he told me about the pictures she took and how she’d saved for her camera. I asked what she carried it in.

“A backpack,” he said. “Wrapped in a sweatshirt, I think.”

At the photography store, I showed him a padded camera bag with adjustable sections inside.

He unfastened it, moved one of the dividers, and grinned.

“She’d love this.”

We got coffee afterward. He asked about my psychology classes; I asked whether his energy project had survived the latest round of calculations. He made a ridiculous thermodynamics joke, and I laughed before I remembered that I no longer needed to laugh on purpose.

For most of the afternoon, I forgot to wonder what Brooke would think if she saw us.

We were looking at camera accessories before leaving when his phone buzzed for the third time in a few minutes. He glanced down and sighed.

“Everything okay?”

He hesitated, then turned the screen slightly toward me.

Brooke had asked whether he was busy. Then what he was doing. Then who was with him. There were more messages underneath, asking about later, about the weekend, about why his answers were taking so long.

“She’s been doing this for days,” he said.

I stopped examining a camera strap.

“Have you told her you’re busy?”

“I keep answering less because every answer starts five more questions.” He locked the screen. “I like her as a friend. But it’s getting hard to feel like I’m allowed to have anything else going on.”

I thought about the first time I’d invited him to hang out specifically because she wanted him. I put the strap back on its hook.

“She’s been under a lot of stress,” I said, though the excuse sounded thin even to me.

“Sure. But she’s always needed to win something. Even when nobody else knew we were competing.”

He shifted the gift bag to his other hand.

“I’m noticing how often somebody else has to look bad for her to feel good.”

I could have told him how familiar that was. Instead, I asked whether he needed wrapping paper, and we headed toward the register.

That weekend, Caleb came over, and we returned to an idea we’d been discussing: a bigger party where couples could bring their partners and single friends could meet people without anybody making it strange.

“Marcus has the space,” Caleb said. “And he’s already offered.”

We asked him, got an enthusiastic yes, and picked a Saturday two weeks away.

I worked on the invitation while Caleb sat beside me. The wording was clear: bring your partner if you had one; come ready to meet people if you didn’t. We created an event page visible to our whole circle.

I checked the settings twice. I wanted Brooke to see it.

People began replying almost immediately. Couples confirmed together. Single friends asked what to bring. A few hours later, Brooke commented, asking whether she should bring somebody or turn up by herself.

I composed and erased several answers before choosing one that sounded effortlessly pleasant.

Whatever works for you. There’ll be plenty of company.

Caleb read it over my shoulder and squeezed my hand.

I imagined her arriving and finding no gap beside him, no confusion she could exploit, no easy laugh at my expense. I returned to the guest list and watched the confirmations come in.

A few days before the party, Caleb and I sat on my bed with the invitation open between us. I closed the laptop.

“I need to know we’re agreeing about this, not just hoping for the same thing.”

“We are.”

“What if she tries to pull you away?”

“I stay with the group.”

“What if she sits between us?”

“I move.” He paused. “Or ask her to. I should’ve been doing that already.”

“I don’t need a performance. I just need to stop feeling like the person you’re willing to inconvenience.”

He looked down at his hands.

“I kept thinking she’d get embarrassed and quit on her own. Every time I avoided saying something, I told myself I was keeping the peace.”

I waited.

“I know,” he said. “Not for you.”

We talked through the things that had happened before: the private errands, the seats, the touches that left me choosing between swallowing my discomfort and looking possessive. He promised he wouldn’t leave me to manage them.

When he put his arms around me, I let myself lean into him.

Tessa called the afternoon before the party.

“Brooke’s telling people this is a setup,” she said. “That you’re inviting her so you can embarrass her in front of everybody.”

I pressed my thumbnail into the edge of my desk.

Tessa lowered her voice.

“Is that what you’re doing?”
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇