Part 7
Brooke’s eyes filled before she seemed to realize she was crying. She searched the room once more. Nobody stepped forward. Near Marcus, two people nodded without speaking.
She picked up her jacket from the couch and struggled to find a sleeve. Then she gave up, bundled it against her chest, and hurried out. Her heels sounded on the steps. The front door shut hard enough to rattle something in the entryway.
I felt an immediate, fierce pleasure.
Then I saw one of the women from my psychology class looking toward the door, her mouth drawn with concern, and my pleasure became difficult to hold onto.
People began talking again. A friend touched my arm and said it was overdue. Someone else thanked Caleb for finally saying it. Across the room, two women spoke quietly together, one glancing toward the stairs.
Caleb took me into the hallway.
“You okay?”
“I don’t know.”
He leaned beside me against the wall.
“I’ve wanted to say that for weeks. I kept waiting for her to understand without making me say it in front of everybody.”
I looked at the floorboards between our shoes.
“I thought I’d feel better than this.”
“I’m sorry I left it so long.” He took my hand. “Do you want to go?”
I shook my head. We returned to the living room, where somebody had turned the music up a little and abandoned the trivia idea.
Marcus found me a few minutes later. He held out his phone.
Brooke had messaged him.
Does everybody hate me now?
He rubbed the back of his neck while I read it.
“I don’t know what to tell her,” he said. “She’s been awful. But that was hard to watch.”
I wanted to remind him about the watch, the movie, the stories she’d invented about me. Instead, I handed his phone back.
He squeezed my shoulder and went to stand with the woman he’d invited.
I tried to join a conversation about classes, but I kept losing track of what people were saying. A few friends approached me brightly, as though we were supposed to celebrate. Others seemed unsure whether to mention Brooke at all.
About an hour later, Owen found me near the kitchen counter.
“I hope you’re not taking all of this on yourself,” he said.
I gave him a small smile.
“She really was out of line,” he continued. He shifted his feet, looked toward the living room, then back at me. “For a long time.”
“I know.”
He nodded, though neither of us looked reassured.
“I’m heading out in a minute. You sure you’re okay?”
“Yeah. Thanks.”
He hugged me quickly and left with a couple of friends. More people followed soon afterward. Marcus hadn’t expected the evening to end so early, but he began collecting cups anyway.
Paige drove me home around midnight. The radio was low, and for the first few blocks she left me alone.
Then she asked, “How are you doing?”
I watched the streetlights pass over the windshield.
“I wanted her to face consequences. I really did.”
“I know.”
“But I keep seeing her trying to put her jacket on.” My voice caught, which irritated me. “I got what I wanted. Now I feel terrible. I don’t know what that says about me.”
Paige reached over and briefly covered my hand.
“You don’t have to settle that in the car.”
At our building, she asked if I wanted her to sit with me for a while. I told her I’d be all right and went upstairs. I left my shoes by the door and went to bed without checking my phone.
The notifications woke me the next morning.
There were messages from more than half a dozen people. Tessa had written a long one saying she was proud I’d stopped accepting Brooke’s behavior. Two other friends said somebody should have confronted her long ago.
Then I reached the others.
One of the women from psychology said she understood why I was upset, but thought the conversation should have happened privately. Another friend said Brooke had been wrong and he still felt sorry for her. A third thought the public confrontation had gone too far.
I read them all, put the phone down, and stared at the ceiling until I heard Paige moving around in the kitchen.
Caleb came over that afternoon. We sat on the couch in our little shared living area, his knee pressed against mine.
“I need to apologize properly,” he said.
“You did last night.”
“For last night. Not for everything before it.”
He rested his forearms on his thighs.
“I kept being nice because I thought nice would make her stop. Really, I was waiting for somebody else to have the uncomfortable conversation.”
I leaned against his shoulder.
“You shouldn’t have had to keep proving there was a problem,” he said. “And it shouldn’t have needed an audience before I did something.”
We sat quietly for a while. I could hear Paige opening and closing a cupboard in the kitchen.
“There’s something I haven’t told you,” I said.
Caleb turned toward me.
“When I started inviting Owen places, it wasn’t just because I thought we’d be friends.”
He didn’t answer.
“I knew how Brooke felt about him. I wanted her to watch him choose my company.”
Caleb looked down at our hands.
“And the girls’ night,” I continued. “I wanted the evening with them. But I also wanted her to see the pictures and know she’d been left out.”
He sat back slowly.
“I get why you were angry.”
“I was so tired of feeling stupid.”
“I know.” He rubbed his thumb across his palm. “Do you feel good about what you did?”
I had been ready for him to be angry, or to tell me it was understandable, or to say Brooke had done worse. The question left me with nowhere useful to look.
“Not all of it,” I said.
He waited, and I made myself finish.
“I liked making her jealous. I liked knowing she’d be hurt. I kept calling it standing up for myself.”
“Some of it was.”
“And some of it wasn’t.”
He nodded.
“Brooke being wrong doesn’t make every choice we made right.”
I pulled a loose thread on the couch cushion until it broke. Caleb took my hand again. Neither of us said anything for a while.
Tessa messaged that evening. Brooke had contacted her with an apology that sounded different from the posts she’d been putting up.
According to Tessa, Brooke admitted she’d been insecure and had taken it out on other women. She wasn’t claiming she’d only been joking. She wanted to know whether there was any way to repair things with the group.
Tessa asked what I thought.
My first response was anger. Brooke had embarrassed me for months, and now, after one awful evening, everyone was supposed to consider how to make her feel welcome again.
I typed a reply, deleted it, and read Tessa’s message once more.
Then I wrote that I needed time. If Brooke genuinely wanted to change how she treated people, I was willing to hear an apology from her directly. That didn’t mean everything would return to how it had been.
Before sending it, I added another paragraph.
I haven’t handled all of this well, either. I’ve been trying to make people feel things instead of just telling them what needed to stop. I need to work on that.
Tessa replied with a heart and said she appreciated my honesty.
I set the phone beside me. Caleb was still there, reading something for class. I put my feet under his leg, and he shifted to make room without looking up.
Over the next three weeks, Brooke kept her distance from us. She still came to an occasional group hangout, and the first time she walked in, I braced myself without meaning to.
She asked Tessa about an assignment. When Tessa answered, Brooke listened. Later, another woman mentioned something she’d bought, and Brooke asked where she’d found it instead of making a joke.
I noticed those things. I also noticed that she chose a chair across the room from Caleb and me.
Caleb began speaking sooner when something bothered him, even when doing it felt awkward. I practiced telling him what I needed before I’d spent a week silently testing whether he would notice. Sometimes I still caught myself composing a clever public reply when a plain private sentence would do. I stopped sending a few of them.
At a game night toward the end of those three weeks, Marcus attempted to explain a rule he clearly hadn’t read. Elise challenged him. Owen reached for the instructions while Tessa accused Marcus of inventing a version in which he couldn’t lose.
Brooke sat at the far end of the table, listening. Caleb nudged my foot beneath my chair.
Marcus offered another ridiculous explanation, even less convincing than the first. I started laughing before he finished. Paige pushed the snack bowl toward me, and I took a handful without missing the next thing he said.
