Part 6
“It’s a party,” I said. “People are bringing their partners. If she can’t leave somebody else’s boyfriend alone, I can’t make that comfortable for her.”
Tessa didn’t answer immediately.
“I get that,” she said at last. “I’ll see you tomorrow.”
After we hung up, I remained at my desk with the phone in my hand. There were things I hadn’t said to her. I hadn’t said how often I’d pictured Brooke being the one who didn’t know where to stand. Or how much I wanted other people present when Caleb finally refused to make room for her.
I opened my shopping list and added more cups.
Marcus had already pushed the furniture back when I arrived the next morning. We carried a table into the kitchen, set up speakers, and argued cheerfully about where to put the food so nobody would block the doorway.
“This house was overdue,” he said, testing the volume. “We’ve been using the living room for laundry and complaining.”
I kept finding jobs. Drinks to chill. Bowls to wash. A cord somebody might trip over.
Paige arrived around noon with ice and more snacks. She watched me rearrange the same stack of cups twice.
“Come sit down.”
“I’m almost done.”
“You’ve been almost done with those cups since I got here.”
I sat beside her on the couch.
“What do you want tonight to do?” she asked.
“I want Brooke to stop.”
“Okay. Anything else?”
I rubbed my palms down my jeans.
“I want her to know what it feels like.”
Paige nodded, not approving, not pretending she hadn’t expected it.
“Which one are you working toward?”
“I don’t know how to pull them apart anymore.”
“Then at least know they’re both there.”
I wanted to tell her Brooke had earned whatever happened. Instead, I got up to empty the ice into the cooler. Paige came over and helped me lift the bag.
By seven, people were arriving steadily. Couples hung their coats together. Single friends collected near the kitchen and began introducing themselves. Marcus had his arm around the woman he’d been seeing, and the music was low enough that nobody had to shout.
Caleb and I greeted people near the entrance. His hand rested at my waist, comfortably, without either of us having to arrange it.
Owen arrived wearing a button-down shirt. I introduced him to several friends, including Elise. When she mentioned photography, he started telling her about his sister’s birthday gift. She asked what kind of camera his sister used, and I left them talking.
Caleb bent toward my ear.
“You doing okay?”
“Actually, yes.”
For a little while, that was true without qualification.
Brooke came in about an hour later. Her fitted dress and heels stood out among the jeans and casual shirts. She paused just inside the room, looking over the people nearest the door, then found Caleb beside me.
He was in the middle of a story to Marcus. His arm stayed where it was.
Brooke approached with an enthusiastic greeting and angled herself toward the space between us. Caleb shifted his feet, keeping me beside him, and finished his sentence before saying hello.
“Come get a drink with me,” she said to him.
“Sure. We’ll come.”
He took my hand and led the way to the kitchen.
Brooke followed. At the table, she picked up a cup and reached for the liquor while Caleb poured a beer.
“This whole thing’s very paired off, isn’t it?” she said. “I feel like I missed the part where single people were supposed to stay home.”
Tessa was scooping ice nearby.
“Half the people here are single,” she said. “We put it right on the invitation.”
A few people laughed. Someone pointed out the group chatting in the doorway. Brooke took a drink and looked away.
Owen joined us a moment later.
“Can you help me with that drink you mentioned?” he asked me. “I’ll get the proportions wrong.”
Brooke set down her cup.
“I can make you something better. There’s a recipe—”
“Thanks, but I wanted to try hers.”
He looked uncomfortable saying it. She moved her hand away from the bottles.
I mixed his drink while we talked about the song playing in the living room. Caleb stayed beside me, his hand resting against my back. When Owen went to find Elise, Brooke watched him go.
Over the next hour, she tried the things that had always worked before.
She called Caleb over to see something on her phone. He looked while standing where he was, then returned to his conversation with Marcus.
She brought up a game they disagreed about, clearly expecting a long argument. He acknowledged her point and asked somebody else a question.
Whenever her hand settled on his arm, he moved naturally into another position. When she suggested they go check something in another room, he invited the rest of us along.
I watched her become louder. Her jokes came more quickly, leaving less room for an answer. She suggested beer pong, and Caleb said we were enjoying talking where we were.
Marcus, looking for something the whole room could join, proposed a trivia game for couples. Partners would answer questions about each other, and everyone else could help judge.
Caleb grinned at me.
“How much trouble are we in?”
Before I could answer, Brooke spoke from beside the couch.
“Probably a lot. I’d do better as his partner.”
Several conversations stopped.
She laughed, but kept going.
“I actually remember what he likes. That should count for something.”
Caleb’s hand went still against mine. He turned fully toward her.
“You don’t know me nearly as well as you think.”
Brooke opened her mouth, smiling as though he’d begun the argument she’d wanted.
He didn’t give her the opening.
“You’ve been insulting my girlfriend for months and calling it humor. I’m done letting you.”
“Oh, come on. I’m messing—”
“No. You’re not.”
Nobody reached for the music. I could hear a cup being set carefully on the table behind me.
“A friend doesn’t make my girlfriend the price of hanging out with me,” Caleb said. “And I’m tired of the competition to prove you’re better than every other woman here.”
Brooke looked toward Marcus, then Tessa.
Caleb waited until she looked back at him.
“Treat her with respect, or stay away from us…”
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇
