Part 2
I got the suitcase down from the closet while Brandon was still trying to explain why that answer didn’t mean what it meant.
He followed me from room to room. When I folded my work clothes, he said I was being dramatic. When I unplugged my bedside lamp, he offered to talk about a timeline. By the time I took my toiletries out of the bathroom, he was promising that everything could change if I would stop packing long enough to listen.
I’d already listened in Wesley’s kitchen.
I had arranged a place to rent while I was searching for a way to leave. That night I took what fit in my car. Caleb helped me move the rest into the new apartment, carrying boxes without asking me to explain anything I couldn’t yet say aloud.
Brandon called the next morning. Then again before lunch. His messages moved from promises to instructions and back again.
We could fix this. I needed to come home. He’d buy a ring if a ring was what I wanted.
I put the phone facedown and went back to finding a place for my plates.
Caleb and I didn’t become a couple that night, or that week. A month passed before we agreed that we were dating. By then, I could sit in my own living room without feeling as though I needed permission to be there.
We went to the next family dinner together.
I’d barely settled my napkin across my lap when Brandon noticed where Caleb’s hand rested beside mine.
His chair struck the wall behind him. A glass fell on its side, sending water toward a basket of rolls, and conversations stopped all around the table.
“You’ve got to be kidding me.” He pointed across the dishes at us. “My own cousin?”
Caleb covered my hand beneath the table.
Brandon’s mother looked from her son to me, then down at our hands. His father put his fork beside his plate.
“Sit down,” he told Brandon. “You’re not shouting through dinner.”
Brandon didn’t seem to hear him. He announced that Caleb had stolen his girlfriend and that I’d left him for someone in his own family. His aunt lifted her napkin to her mouth. I saw two relatives exchange a startled look, and my face grew hot.
Caleb let go of my hand and stood.
“Don’t turn this into something it wasn’t,” he said. “She moved out. You were broken up for a month before we started dating.”
“You expect anybody to believe that?”
“It’s what happened. You know it.”
Brandon called him a liar. Caleb’s jaw tightened, but his voice didn’t rise.
Then Vanessa pushed her chair back.
“Oh, sit down, Brandon.”
I braced for whatever she was about to say about me.
Instead, she looked at her brother with an expression I’d usually seen aimed in my direction.
“She put up with this family for years and somehow stayed decent to all of us. You barely noticed. Let her be with somebody who does.”
Brandon rounded on her.
She ignored him and looked at me. “He’s lucky. I hope you’re happy.”
I couldn’t get a word out before Brandon started shouting again, this time about his sister taking sides.
Their mother rose and told them both to stop. Then she came around the table, touched my elbow, and asked me to help her in the kitchen.
The door swung shut behind us. On the stove, a pan of gravy had formed a skin around the edge. She turned the burner off before facing me.
“Please,” she said. “Tell me what I’m missing.”
I told her about the window at Wesley’s house. I described standing at the refrigerator while her son explained the difference between the woman he lived with and the woman he intended to marry.
She gripped the back of a kitchen chair.
“Natalie?” she asked quietly.
I nodded. “He said he was waiting for her.”
She pressed her lips together, and her eyes filled.
“I thought we were waiting for a ring,” I said. “I didn’t know I was waiting for him to choose someone else.”
She crossed the kitchen and put her arms around me. She was shorter than I was; I could see the silver roots at the part in her hair while she cried against my shoulder.
“I had an outfit picked out in my head,” she said. “For your wedding. Isn’t that foolish?”
I shook my head.
She drew back, keeping her hands on my arms. “You gave him five years. You don’t owe him another one.”
Through the door, Brandon’s voice rose again.
“I don’t blame you,” she said. “And Caleb’s a good man. I’m glad you’ve got someone who sees you.”
We hugged again. A moment later, the front door slammed hard enough to make a serving spoon tremble on the counter. An engine revved outside, followed by the sharp complaint of tires on the street.
When we returned to the dining room, someone had blotted up the spilled water and put a folded towel under Brandon’s glass.
Jonah, Caleb’s older brother, leaned back in his chair.
“Well. He’s always preferred an exit with sound effects.”
A few people laughed too quickly. Caleb’s father muttered that a drive might cool him off, and dishes began moving around the table again.
Nobody quite recovered the conversation we’d been having. But his aunt asked about my promotion and waited for the answer. An uncle recommended a restaurant to Caleb and me. Their grandmother reached past the breadbasket and laid her small, dry hand on mine.
“I’m pleased you’re not leaving us,” she said.
I turned my hand over and held hers until she was ready to let go.
For the next week, Brandon’s messages arrived before I got out of bed and after I’d turned out the light. He begged in one, insulted me in the next, then sent a paragraph about how I was using Caleb to punish him.
I saved them. When the insults grew worse, I took screenshots and put copies somewhere I wouldn’t lose them. Then I blocked his number.
The quiet lasted until mutual friends began sending me his posts. He was sharing quotations about disloyal relatives, poisonous people, betrayal. He didn’t use our names. He didn’t need to.
I showed Caleb one while we were waiting for a table somewhere.
He read it, handed my phone back, and asked whether I wanted to sit outside.
“That’s all you’ve got?” I asked.
“He can have his page,” Caleb said. “I’m not spending dinner on it.”
That Saturday, Paige arrived at my apartment with coffee and more empty boxes. I’d lived there for six weeks, and pictures were still propped against the wall. She set our drinks on the floor and began sorting a box labeled kitchen that contained mostly bathroom things.
“Excellent system,” she said.
“I was under pressure.”
She smiled, then grew serious.
“I’m happy you’re happy. But are you sure you’re ready? Five years is a lot to get over in six weeks.”
I sat on the floor beside her.
“I didn’t start leaving six weeks ago. I started in April, at Wesley’s. I spent two months sleeping next to him after I heard that conversation.”
Paige peeled a strip of tape off a box.
“By the time I moved out, I’d already been alone for a while.”
She nodded. “Okay. That makes more sense.”
For a few minutes, we worked without talking. Then she carried my mugs to the cabinets and kept her back to me.
“I should’ve said something about Brandon a long time ago.”
I stopped wrapping a picture frame.
“I never liked how he treated you,” she said. “You’d get everything handled for him, and he’d act like showing up was his contribution. I kept thinking if I pushed, you’d feel like you had to defend him.”
I remembered all the times she’d gone quiet while I explained why he was tired, distracted, busy.
She put the last mug away and turned around.
“I’ve had dinner with Caleb once. He listened when you talked. Brandon spent five years waiting for his turn.”
My eyes burned. I bent over the wrapping paper so she wouldn’t have to watch me deal with it.
Two evenings later, Caleb picked me up without telling me where we were going. He only said I should be hungry.
The restaurant had handmade pasta and a reservation list I’d once shown Brandon while we ate takeout on the couch. Brandon had looked at the prices and passed my phone back. I’d mentioned it to Caleb in the middle of some other conversation, hardly expecting him to retain it.
He opened the restaurant door and caught my expression.
“You said the menu looked good.”
Inside, a candle sat low between us, and the windows reflected our table once it grew dark. Caleb asked about a project at work. Halfway through my answer, he remembered the name of the problem I’d described the week before and asked whether it had been resolved.
He wanted to hear about my parents and my childhood, and about the plans I’d had before adulthood got so busy. In return, I heard about his work overseas and the morning he’d spent waiting in the wrong office. We were still trading stories long after the plates had been cleared.
When the check arrived, he dealt with it and continued listening to my story.
Outside, I slipped my hand into his before we reached the car.
The following evening, I was stirring dinner when somebody knocked. I turned down the stove and went to the door.
Brandon filled the peephole…
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇
