Part 3
I hadn’t given him my address.
The spoon was still in my hand. I carried it back to the kitchen, set it on a plate, and returned to the door without deciding what to do.
Another knock came, harder.
Then I heard Caleb’s voice in the hallway. He’d been keeping a few things at my place and had a key. The lock turned, and I pulled the door open just far enough for him to come inside.
Brandon started forward with him.
“Wait out here,” Caleb said.
He stepped in, saw my face, and lowered his voice. “Do you want to talk to him?”
“No.”
Caleb turned back to the doorway.
“She doesn’t want a conversation. You need to go.”
Brandon tried to look around him. “I didn’t come to see you.”
“I know. She said no.”
I stood beside the kitchen counter where Brandon couldn’t quite see me. Caleb shifted when his cousin leaned sideways.
“You don’t get to decide who she talks to,” Brandon said.
“She just decided.”
Brandon planted a hand on the frame and pushed forward. Caleb braced himself in the opening. He was bigger, but until that moment I’d never seen the difference used for anything more consequential than reaching a high shelf.
“Back up,” Caleb said.
Brandon pushed again. Caleb didn’t give him room.
After a few seconds, Brandon retreated into the hall and began shouting. Five years, he said. I owed him. I couldn’t keep hiding behind his cousin.
“She owes you nothing,” Caleb told him. “Come here again and we call the police.”
Brandon lingered, breathing hard. Then he turned toward the stairs.
Caleb waited until the outer door closed before locking mine. He fastened the chain, turned, and found me gripping the counter with both hands.
He crossed the room and held me while I tried to get air into my chest. My dinner began to burn. Neither of us moved until the smell reached us, and then he switched off the stove without letting go of my hand.
We sat on the couch after I stopped trembling.
“If he does that again, we need to ask about a protective order,” Caleb said. “And I can stay here more, if you want.”
I nodded against his shoulder.
Three days later, Brandon’s mother called about Jonah’s birthday party.
I hesitated long enough for her to understand.
“Brandon won’t be there,” she said. “Caleb told me what happened. I told my son he wasn’t welcome this weekend.”
“I don’t want everyone rearranging things because of me.”
“This is because of him. Jonah wants you there. So do we.”
The party was at Brandon’s parents’ house that Saturday. His mother hugged me at the door, and his father waited until I’d put down my bag before apologizing.
“He had no business coming to your home,” he said. “I’m sorry he frightened you.”
Jonah’s wife handed me a drink and drew me toward the others. All afternoon, someone seemed to find a reason to sit beside me. An uncle asked about work. An aunt had written down the title of a book she thought I’d like. Jonah thanked me for coming as if I’d done him a favor instead of spending half the afternoon eating his birthday cake.
I was in the kitchen refilling my glass when Vanessa came in and closed the door.
My shoulders tightened before she said a word.
“I owe you an apology,” she began.
I put the drink down.
She leaned against the counter, looking annoyed with herself.
“Mom talked about you constantly. How helpful you were, how thoughtful, how well you were doing at work. I started hearing every nice thing she said about you as something she wasn’t saying about me.”
“Vanessa—”
“I know. It’s not flattering.” She looked at me directly. “I was jealous, and I made it your problem.”
She admitted the comments, the coldness, the unnecessary little cuts. Then she gave an uncomfortable laugh.
“This is going to sound ridiculous, but now that you’re not dating my brother, I can stop acting like we’re competing to be Mom’s favorite daughter.”
I almost smiled.
“You look happy with Caleb,” she said. “I’d like to know you without being awful first. Could we try again?”
“We could,” I said.
She lifted her glass a fraction. “Good. I’m much more entertaining when I’m not threatened.”
Over the following weeks, we began meeting for coffee. She was sharp and funny, with an exact memory for things people wished she’d forgotten. Gradually, she told me about growing up with Brandon.
When he broke something, someone else had upset him. When he wanted something, their parents found a way to get it. Their mother had been especially good at supplying reasons for behavior that needed consequences instead.
Vanessa told me about other girlfriends, too. He’d kept each of them waiting the same way.
“He never thought anybody would actually stop,” she said, stirring her coffee.
One afternoon, Caleb came in from work and sat beside me without taking off his shoes. He told me his boss had offered him a promotion.
“That’s wonderful,” I said.
Then he explained that accepting meant making his overseas assignment permanent. He’d have to leave for at least three years.
I folded the corner of the cushion cover under my fingers.
“I turned it down,” he said.
I stared at him.
He winced. “I should probably have started there.”
“Are you sure?”
“Yes. I’ve just come home. I want a life here, with you. The job’s good. That doesn’t make it the right life.”
We had only been together a matter of months. I asked again anyway, searching his face for the sacrifice he might someday hold against me.
He pulled me closer. “I’m staying.”
That night, we talked until we should have been asleep. He wanted us engaged within a year, married the following year. He wanted children eventually, if I did, and asked what timing I imagined. He’d even looked at areas with good schools, though neither of us was ready to need one.
The next week, Brandon’s version of our breakup began circulating again. A coworker sent screenshots from a group conversation: according to him, I’d been sneaking around with Caleb for months, then used his cousin to get revenge.
I read the messages twice and didn’t answer them.
Then Wesley asked to meet.
I arrived at the café expecting him to defend his friend. Instead, he moved his untouched cup aside and apologized.
“Brandon told me when you left,” he said. “He told me you ended it before anything happened with Caleb. Now he’s telling people something else.”
Wesley had already corrected him in their friend group. He’d also told them what Brandon had said at the barbecue.
“A few of them believed him at first,” he admitted. “They don’t now.”
I thanked him, but he shook his head.
“There’s more I need to own. I laughed that day. You were carrying drinks out to us, and I let him talk about you like that.” He looked down at his hands. “I should’ve stopped it.”
“Yes,” I said. “You should have.”
He nodded without trying to make it easier for himself.
“But thank you for telling the truth now.”
By the time Caleb and I had been dating three months, we were ready for a weekend away. We drove to a small beach town called Merewick, somewhere I’d wanted to visit for years.
On trips with Brandon, the itinerary belonged to him. Asking to change a plan usually spoiled the next several hours. With Caleb, we spread a brochure across the bed and took turns circling things.
I wanted more beach time instead of a museum. He folded the brochure and reached for the sunscreen. He wanted seafood one evening; I didn’t, so we walked another block and found a place that suited us both.
On our last evening, the sand had cooled beneath us and the light was fading off the water when he grew quiet.
“I keep trying to find the right way to say this,” he said.
I turned toward him.
“I’m falling in love with you. Have been since those coffees, really. I know I said too much before you were free to hear it. But getting to be with you, watching you start to trust yourself again…” He shook his head. “I’m glad you let me stay.”
“I love you, too.”
The answer came without rehearsal or the fear that I’d said it first. He kissed me, then pulled me against him while the last people on the beach gathered their towels.
At home, I posted a few pictures from the trip.
Two mornings later, an email from Brandon waited in my inbox. He accused me of using him for security, planning my departure for months, wasting years he could have spent with someone who cared. Beneath his address, in the copied field, was his mother’s…
To read the rest of the story – CLICK the NEXT button 👇👇👇
